November 28, 2009 (NCAA Championship)
Wisconsin-Whitewater 45, Illinois Wesleyan 7

November 21, 2009 (NCAA Championship)
Illinois Wesleyan 41, Wabash 35 (2 OTs)

November 14, 2009
Illinois Wesleyan 49, North Park 0
Augustana 42, Millikin 13
North Central 49, Elmhurst 24
Carthage 35, Wheaton 30

November 7, 2009
Carthage 55, North Park 24
Illinois Wesleyan 20, Wheaton 17
North Central 45, Augustana 26
Millikin 36, Elmhurst 34 (3 OTs)

October 31, 2009
Carthage 41, Millikin 28
Augustana 42, North Park 14
Wheaton 38, Elmhurst 7
Illinois Wesleyan 28, North Central 22 (OT)

October 24, 2009
Augustana 42, Carthage 20
Illinois Wesleyan 20, Elmhurst 7
Millikin 35, North Park 7
North Central 27, Wheaton 7

October 17, 2009
Wheaton 41, Millikin 7
Elmhurst 47, North Park 10
Illinois Wesleyan 7, Augustana 0
North Central 63, Carthage 48

October 10, 2009
Millikin 19, Illinois Wesleyan 13
Wheaton 24, Augustana 17
Carthage 45, Elmhurst 38
North Central 83, North Park 7

October 3, 2009
Wheaton 41, North Park 6
North Central 58, Millikin 0
Illinois Wesleyan 42, Carthage 16
Augustana 21, Elmhurst 3

September 26, 2009
Carthage 34, Valparaiso 24
North Central 69, Olivet 18
Elmhurst 31, Chicago 6
Wheaton 32, Hope 20

September 19, 2009
Benedictine 27, North Park 17
Millikin 30, Albion 13
Augustana 31, Wisconsin-Platteville 12
Illinois Wesleyan 52, Aurora 6
Wheaton 54, Concordia (Wis.) 3
Carthage 50, Lakeland (Wis.) 34

September 12, 2009
Carthage 26, Hope 19
Elmhurst 17, Olivet 9
Illinois Wesleyan 43, Alma 7
Wheaton 29, Bethel 26
Augustana 42, Greenville 20
Rose-Hulman 48, North Park 17
North Central 55, Benedictine 0
Millikin 42, Loras 7

September 5, 2009
Ohio Northern 28, North Central 19
Illinois Wesleyan 28, Hope 25
Coe 9, Augustana 7
Millikin 44, Illinois College 28
Elmhurst 24, Benedictine 14
North Park 17, Carroll 10