May 15
Game #1: Illinois Wesleyan 6, North Central 1
Game #2: Carthage 6, Elmhurst 3
Game #3: North Central 3, Elmhurst 1
Game #4: Carthage 9, Illinois Wesleyan 3

May 16
Game #5: Illinois Wesleyan 10, North Central 7
Game #6: Illinois Wesleyan 5, Carthage 4
Game #7: Carthage 11, Illinois Wesleyan 1