Friday, May 1, 2009
Round One
#3 Illinois Wesleyan def. #6 Elmhurst 6-1
#4 Augustana def. #5 North Central 6-2 

Semifinals
#2 Wheaton def. Illinois Wesleyan 7-2 
#1 Carthage def. Augustana 5-2

Fifth Place Match
North Central def. Elmhurst 6-3 

Saturday, May 2, 2009
Third Place Match
Augustana def. Illinois Wesleyan 6-3

Championship
Carthage def. Wheaton 6-3