April 29, 2009
Wheaton def. Illinois Wesleyan 8-1

April 28, 2009
Wheaton def. North Central 7-2

April 25, 2009
Augustana def. Wheaton 5-4
Augustana def. Elmhurst 7-2
Wheaton def. Elmhurst 8-1

April 23, 2009
Illinois Wesleyan def. North Central 5-4

April 22, 2009
Carthage def. Elmhurst 7-2

April 18, 2009
Carthage def. Illinois Wesleyan 6-3
Illinois Wesleyan def. Augustana 6-3
Carthage def. Augustana 6-3

April 13, 2009
Carthage def. North Central 6-3

April 9, 2009
North Central def. Elmhurst 8-1

April 8, 2009
Carthage def. Wheaton 6-3

April 4, 2009
Illinois Wesleyan def. Elmhurst 9-0

March 14, 2009
North Central def. Augustana 6-3