| Tournament Schedule (Subject to Change - Updated as of 5/10/21) |
| Thursday, May 6 |
| Game 1: #8 Augustana 5, #9 Elmhurst 4 |
| Game 2: #3 Carthage 8, #6 North Park 1 |
| Game 3: #2 Illinois Wesleyan 4, #7 Wheaton 1 |
| Game 4: #5 North Central 6, #4 Carroll 0 |
| Game 5: #1 Millikin 9, #8 Augustana 5 |
| Saturday, May 8 |
| Game 6: #9 Elmhurst 8, #6 North Park 7 |
| Game 7: #4 Carroll 6, #8 Augustana 0 |
| Game 8: #7 Wheaton 10, #9 Elmhurst 8 |
| Game 9: #2 Illinois Wesleyan 4, #3 Carthage 1 |
| Game 10: #1 Millikin 7, #5 North Central 6 |
| Thursday, May 13 |
| Game 11: #4 Carroll 4, #3 Carthage 1 |
| Game 12: #5 North Central 8, #7 Wheaton 1 |
| Friday, May 14 |
| Game 13: #1 Millikin 1, #2 Illinois Wesleyan 0 |
| Game 14: #4 Carroll 0, #5 North Central 3 |
| Game 15: #2 Illinois Wesleyan 7, #5 North Central 3 |
| Saturday, May 15 (@Millikin) |
| Game 16: #1 Millikin 8, #2 Illinois Wesleyan 0 |