The 2021 Indoor All-Conference list was determined by the CCIW's Honor Role at TFRRS, based upon performances between January 30 and March 6. The top 8 individuals and top 4 relays in each event were designated "all-conference". 

Men's Recipients

Augustana
Urvaksh Avanthsa
Kyle Baus
Dean Check
Carson Eipers
Michael Gille
Connor McBride
Ian Rothery
Josh Teets
Ryan Thornton
Mason Wright
 
Carroll
Kyle Adams
Cooper Albert
Zach Benes
David Burgess
Maxwell Campbell
David Gilbert
Caleb Jacques-Hembree
Steven Hermsen
Jimmy Hinkley
Spencer Kirsteatter
Kevin Lind
Peter Marra
Nathan Raatz
 
Carthage
Matt Ausse
Josh Atlas
Michael Barber
Connor Bell
Cody Canegan
Topher Davis
Cameron Fischer
Alassane Guisse
Craig Hundley
Edelmar Morales-Rivera
Alex Pitrone
David Rogers
Diego Torrez
Joseph White
 
Elmhurst
Matt Tobin
 
Illinois Wesleyan
Zach Anderson
Cyrus Clarke
Jake Maheffey
Sam Morris
Kade Murray
Davis Nguy
Zach Orpilla
Liam Owens
Sam Painter
Cole Paraday
Ethan Ruth
Drew Tatlock
Matt Wagner
 
Millikin
Jackson Allen
Kristian Boado
Joey Davies
Marshun Hart
Ben Kuxman
Max Rogers
Jake Shumaker
Dalton Spencer
 
North Central
Matthew Boelke
Gavin Carr
Kevin Dixon
Jason England
Cameron Green
Riley Hughes
Nick Janca
Matthew Jett
Kendall Johnson
Clark Kelly
Trevor LaMirande
Andrew Lehman
James McGlashon
Gabe Pommier
Connor Riss
Michael Shuff
Jamauri Spivery
Michael Stanley
Max Svienty
 
North Park
Jason Adkinson
Daniel Dwight
Terence Hollis
Aeneas Lanier
 
Wheaton
Dolan Bair
David Bradley
Nico Bradley
Isaiah Clausen
Don Crowder
Jeremy Earnst
Trevor Gabrielle
Jediah Giller
Ben Jackson
Jonah Jones
Andrew Lauber
Elijah Nitz
Eli Odell
Kevin Riley
Peter Van Os
Max Veth
Peter Watson

Women's Recipients

Augustana
Jayla Hathorn
Katrina Krebasch
Jordan MacNeil
Kalli Majewski
Sofia Wajner
 
Carroll
Morgan Davister
Lexi Elegbede-Peer
Josie Eberle
Sarah Gomez
Sydney Halversen
Jessica Mueller
Jamie Pankratz
Alli Spitzer
Vanessa Uitenbroek
Haiden Zimmerman
 
Carthage
Cailey Ciezadlo
Julia Cozzi
Hannah Lizano
Alexis Mattox
Pearl Moss
Audrey Tesch
 
Elmhurst
Mallory Burke
Stefania Camaci
Emily Clausen
Emily Gilligan
Huda Hussaini
Lauren Mack
Erin Matthias
Amanda Lams
Stacia Landry
Alyssa Rafuse
Elita Spadlowski
Sarah Stephens
 
Illinois Wesleyan
Ayana Blair
Addison Bendery
Lexie Dorsey
Rebekah Harden
Emma Helferich
Mckinlee Miller
Jenna Mirande
Katie North
Avery Smith
Katie Vogler
Cora Wilkinson
Camryn Winterland
Lauren Wong
Kelsey Wyman
 
Millikin
Brea Blackwell
Quincy Collings
Anne Longman
Brianna Niebrugge
Stephanie Oliver
Adriyanna Patterson
Eryn Renison
Katie Risner
Alyssa Ruiz
Maddie Russelburg
Alyssa Vignos
Hailey Wimberly
 
North Central
Julia Babinec
Julianne Billings
Madeline Bobinski
Kaitlin Bonney
Riley Chambers
Anna Cotter
Alexandra Draves
Jenna Fiore
Stephanie Garcia
Allison Grady
Alexis Henz
Elizabeth Hodonicky
Kiarah Horn
Marcedes Jackson
Faith Ladin
Riley Lyons
Kelsey McLaurin
Emmy Mussey
Kathy Myrda
Denise Partee
Rachael Vaccaro
Jenna Yakesh
 
Wheaton
Kaitlin Armstrong
Susannah Bennett
Hope Clark
Audrey Coyle
Olivia Eisses
Emma Fisler
Faith Gilbert
Abi Gum
Brianna Hawthorne
Sydney Jones
Amy Keane
Alyssa Mantia
Ally Lyle
Tess Sutton